MundoAudiofilo HiFi Forum

Meet fellow Audiophiles and Music lovers from around the world
 
HomeCalendarGalleryFAQSearchMemberlistUsergroupsRegisterLog in

How much do you really need to spend to reach the high end sound? 5 5 1
Share | 
 

 How much do you really need to spend to reach the high end sound?

View previous topic View next topic Go down 
Goto page : 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6  Next
AuthorMessage
sceptic



Join date: 2009-09-08
Posts: 145

PostSubject: How much do you really need to spend to reach the high end sound?   Sat Apr 24, 2010 4:01 pm

A forum member has been quoted as saying just how easily attainable it is to reach the high end in terms of sound quality but at the same time we are asked to pay 10s of thousands for the privilege, do we really need to spend bucket loads on stands, cables, tweaks, cd players to reach the peak and reach our audio nirvana?
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Ozexpat



England Join date: 2010-04-02
Trade:
  • No

Posts: 646
Location: Oxfordshire
Age: 52

PostSubject: Re: How much do you really need to spend to reach the high end sound?   Sat Apr 24, 2010 5:17 pm

It depends on personal circumstances. What you like is just as subjective as wine or fast cars. A great sound can be achieved by spending wisely, careful selection of components and setting them up properly. To use a motoring analogy, if you have never driven a Ferrari then a Golf GTi may well feel fast enough. Aspiration is what keeps high end companies (in all fields) in business. Audio nirvana is not the preserve of the mega rich.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
sceptic



Join date: 2009-09-08
Posts: 145

PostSubject: Re: How much do you really need to spend to reach the high end sound?   Sat Apr 24, 2010 7:19 pm

A Golf compared to Ferrari are easily measurable we have figures that prove the performance advantages are real, we don't have that with HiFi we just have ears and prices.

I like your point about careful selection as these are the basic ingredients to start from.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Ozexpat



England Join date: 2010-04-02
Trade:
  • No

Posts: 646
Location: Oxfordshire
Age: 52

PostSubject: Re: How much do you really need to spend to reach the high end sound?   Sat Apr 24, 2010 7:58 pm

My point was about personal perception.

Take a bottle of wine. I love big, bold , brassy Oz Cabernet. I have been lucky enough to have consumed some very well known and supposed top end French Cabernets. These wines are considered the best wines in the world according to wine experts. Very few float my boat. They don't give me the flavour I am looking for but cost many times the price.

High end gear is perceived as better because it is expensive and somebody else says it is what we should all want. But if you can find something you like and enjoy, why bother spending a fortune on gear which is considered high end.
Unless of course you hear something you like and aspire to achieving that sound.


Last edited by Ozexpat on Sat Apr 24, 2010 7:59 pm; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : syntax error)
Back to top Go down
View user profile
dvv



Serbia Join date: 2009-10-20
Trade:
  • Yes

Posts: 3262
Location: Serbia
Age: 58

PostSubject: Re: How much do you really need to spend to reach the high end sound?   Sat Apr 24, 2010 9:22 pm

To answer the question above - surprisingly little, provided someone who knows his stuff decides you should have superior sound without having to pay through your nose.

By this, I mean that somebody should really pay attention, be thorough and not be afraid to look the beast in the eye, but all that will be worthless unless the person buying it cannot do the same.

Consider the concepts involved.

High End is always expensive. By extrapolation, if it ain't expensive, it ain't High End. Nobody will actually utter that, but that's what you are told by the ads and, unfortunately, some dealers.

High End is big, massive, a good High End amp will weigh in at least 60 lbs. While there is some justification for this technically, assuming a lot of power, but in real life, NOBODY, most certainly not the dealers who just tried to flog you a 100 lbs mammoth amp, will tell you that is that's so, how come he charges to goddamn much for his tube gear, which rarely manages 50 WPC, let alone the kiloWatts some solid state models do.

High End lives not in cases, but in sculptured madness these days, typical case price is well over 500 quid. They turn you into an aluminium reseller in the end. And no, you do not have the option of a classic pressed steel case along with a discount, because you went in to buy sound, not metalwork.

But all that has absolutely nothing to do with how they sound, and in my view, most of the High End in terms of price and public perception is, at the very best, worth about 10% of its price. Most, not all. And I kid you not!

Lastly, you have your own perception. Like it or not, but you have already been brainwashed, the question is only to what extent. If you have managed to keep your sanity, and if they try people can do that, then you will reject the packaging and go for the essence.

To get there, you first of all need to know what you are looking for, you have to have some frame of reference, and for that to happen, you need solid experience and an open mind. You do not need a big, deep wallet.

Gifted people come in all sorts of packages. Some are economically savvy and play by the rules, others are more realistic and think in real world numbers. As an example, think of England, narrow down to Somerset, zoom in on Taunton. That's where a very, but VERY wise man lives, and goes by the name of Lindley-Hood. And he's been around longer than even me, which was great for me, because I learnt much from that man. Above all, I learnt to be able to close my eyes, empty my mind and get down to the music itself. In audio, no greater gift is possible.

Anyway, that man has produced several projects and most of them sound excellent, some are exceptional, and one or two downright outstanding. Your first sure fire way to sound no Hign End device would be ashamed of having is to build some of those projects, either by yourself, or with the help of a friend versed in matters electronic. I menation this because it's easily the most cost effective use of your money.

The next possibility is to buy a known good unit and tune it up. You can play that game with a very low profile, or you can hog it, your choice. You can ask here, but in any case, I would advise you Google around, there are many DIY and tuning sites. with invaluable information.

Following this, you can go up half a step, by doing as described in the above paragraph, but using as a base a well chose vintage device. With them, half of your work is already done, because 30 years ago, the manufacturers were much more thorough at the very start. This requires a good knowledge of both electronics and vintage gear.

Or you can simply go by the price and remortgage the house.
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://www.dezorel.com
ears



England Join date: 2009-09-05
Trade:
  • No

Posts: 254

PostSubject: Re: How much do you really need to spend to reach the high end sound?   Sat Apr 24, 2010 10:14 pm

I'm pleasantly surprised by just how good a sound you can get today from the likes of CA , NAD for not a great deal of money.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
JSBach



australia Join date: 2009-10-10
Trade:
  • No

Posts: 1044
Location: Australia

PostSubject: Re: How much do you really need to spend to reach the high end sound?   Sat Apr 24, 2010 10:37 pm

ears wrote:
I'm pleasantly surprised by just how good a sound you can get today from the likes of CA , NAD for not a great deal of money.

You can put together a system that takes you into the heart and soul of the music for way less than silly money. You can also spend an absolute fortune on ultra expensive 'high-end' gear, mismatch it, use it in an acoustically horrid room ( as the majority of those spending silly money do affraid) and end up with very nasty noises, but hey, you'll impress your friends.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
adam



spain Join date: 2009-09-05
Trade:
  • Yes

Posts: 4281
Location: Spain
Age: 42

PostSubject: Re: How much do you really need to spend to reach the high end sound?   Sun Apr 25, 2010 8:23 am

I question I've thought about is do you really need the ultra high end in a modern sized room and house? Most if not all high end gear tends to be high powered and demanding big speakers, these type of products always cost, but if you live in a small house with neighbours what are the changes you'll ever need that kind of system?

I think that if for example you listen near field in a small room it is much more easier to put together a really good sound for not a great deal, for about 1000euros for example you can get something amazing sounding.
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://www.eden-audio.com
dvv



Serbia Join date: 2009-10-20
Trade:
  • Yes

Posts: 3262
Location: Serbia
Age: 58

PostSubject: Re: How much do you really need to spend to reach the high end sound?   Sun Apr 25, 2010 8:40 am

Adam, I'd just love to be amazed by a 1.000 euro system, but unfortunately, I haven't been so far. Decent sounding - yes, it is possible, but it takes a lot to amaze me. Even if you buy vintage, after refreshing, it will cost more. But your point is not lost on me, it's true you don't need five figure systems for an honestly good sound.
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://www.dezorel.com
The Boss



England Join date: 2009-09-09
Trade:
  • No

Posts: 380

PostSubject: Re: How much do you really need to spend to reach the high end sound?   Sun Apr 25, 2010 9:34 am

At what price points do you think diminishing returns really starts to bite hard?
Back to top Go down
View user profile
dvv



Serbia Join date: 2009-10-20
Trade:
  • Yes

Posts: 3262
Location: Serbia
Age: 58

PostSubject: Re: How much do you really need to spend to reach the high end sound?   Sun Apr 25, 2010 9:57 am

The Boss wrote:
At what price points do you think diminishing returns really starts to bite hard?


I do believe that is next to impossible to say simply because we have an added spice in the whole mix, and that is synergy. I have seen and heard systems costing around 1,500 euros which sounded like they cost 4 or 5 times that, but I've also heard similarly priced systems which weren't worth 10% of their asking price, modest as it may be. Exactly the same goes for the High End, but there you do have a redeeming value. If you buy an all Krell system, you know you'll get excellent amplification, but their CD player, while truly very good, may not be the best deal around that price, yet you are assured that you will still have premium value and above you, you know those two will fit in as perfectly as is humanly possible. Which leaves you to choose your speakers, and choosing them is as personal as it gets.

Off hand, I'd say that above about 1.000 euros per unit and 2.000 euros per loudspeaker pair, you are starting to pay more for something that is not concerned with sound. Looks, design, name, whatever.

The speakers are the really interesting part. UK has always been THE leader in Europe regarding speaker kits, and there are some venerable and respected names in that business - e.g. Wilmslow. I would definitely go for one of their kits, because most are well designed and well balanced, because you have an excellent choice in size, complexity and price, and because they are reputed to have an outstanding after sales support.

The speakers are the most overpriced items in any system, I guarantee it. They are big and heavy, and their shipping alone rockets the price no matter how you look at it. Then it's the add-on value; a manufacturer will typically use say 22 mm thick MDF for the front baffle, and usually 19 mm MDF for the rest, reasonable since it's the front baffle that has to absorb approximately 90% of the total mechanical energy produced by the drivers. So, instead of 22, you use 25 or 28 mm thick MDF, and 22 or 25 mm MDF for the rest. It will end up being much sturdier and heavier, but since there's no shipping involved, what do you care? We all know mass is always good in speakers, you simply can't go wrong. Next, instead of the supplied parts, you can always use better parts and/or composite capacitors (putting in parallel different types to avoid the pitfalls of each type), and instead of using a printed circuit board for the crossover, you can go point-to-point soldering, instead of those crappy wirewound resistors, you can use metal oxyde resistors, etc. In short, you can do simple things to it which are typically reserved for speakers with 5 number price tags, and I guarantee it, you WILL reap the sonic benefits.

Not to even mention the satisfaction you will have once they are complete and working. And you can change, tune or upgrade them at will.
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://www.dezorel.com
Ozexpat



England Join date: 2010-04-02
Trade:
  • No

Posts: 646
Location: Oxfordshire
Age: 52

PostSubject: Re: How much do you really need to spend to reach the high end sound?   Sun Apr 25, 2010 4:25 pm

Quote:
Lastly, you have your own perception. Like it or not, but you have already been brainwashed, the question is only to what extent. If you have managed to keep your sanity, and if they try people can do that, then you will reject the packaging and go for the essence.


Good point. Many people cannot tell the difference if you play a piece of music on one CD player from another, or through different speakers. While I agree many can hear a difference between a great system and a poor system, how many would think that money could be better spent on music for the said system ? The fact that sales of compressed downloads and iPods are increasing at an exponential rate gives credance to that.

Even amongst the enlightened there are a number who cannot really notice an improvement but because the product is something that has received rave reviews, it is therefore somehow better.
For those of us who have the passion to be questioning these issues, we have already been influenced by the marketting either at a retailer or in Audioporn.
Like an addict, we must resist the easy option and retrain ourselves to believe in what we hear, not in what we believe we need.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Fnuckle



England Join date: 2010-04-03
Trade:
  • Yes

Posts: 205

PostSubject: Re: How much do you really need to spend to reach the high end sound?   Sun Apr 25, 2010 5:27 pm

There's a couple of chicken and egg situations going on in high-end. The first is the notion that big, expensive products are good simply because they are big and expensive. If the system sounds poor, it's because the listener haven't spent enough or bought large enough equipment. I've heard some exceptionally good products that sound better than bigger counterparts, but it doesn't matter.

American hi-fi buffs are particularly bad for this. It's why big monobloks in between the speakers are so popular there; it's conspicuous spending, because they are so visible.

The other is making loudspeakers so insensitive and difficult to drive that they demand big amplifiers to drive them. This also works if you have a mindset that thinks bigger is better.

When I used to do the CES, you'd have to set up the biggest equipment you could. If you put up a smaller system, no matter how good it sounded, the audiophiles would walk past laughing.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
dvv



Serbia Join date: 2009-10-20
Trade:
  • Yes

Posts: 3262
Location: Serbia
Age: 58

PostSubject: Re: How much do you really need to spend to reach the high end sound?   Sun Apr 25, 2010 6:44 pm

Fnuckle wrote:
...

American hi-fi buffs are particularly bad for this. It's why big monobloks in between the speakers are so popular there; it's conspicuous spending, because they are so visible.

...


While I can confirm this from my own experience, I would, just for the record, say that I also plan monoblock amps, each in its own case. The reason, however, is purely technical, I need the extra space for a full volatge regulation, which in itself is just another power amplifier, and needs its own heat sinks just as the audio part does.

Point is, as usually happens, they have taken a valid technical point and turned it into a marketing ploy. Although, in case of megawatt amps, they DO need all the heat sinking they can muster, given that they use anything upwards of 20 power transistors.

I would also add that the American thirst for power stems from two reasons, not counting their wastefulness also observed elsewhere. One is that they generally have, by Euro standards, VERY large living rooms, and making it all come alive in a big room does require more power, although not as much as they seem to believe. The other is that they, just as we, have been let down by the general audio industry offerings, in that you need a 100 WPC rating these days to get just half of that as decent power. Savings in audio hit the power supplies first, unfortunately.
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://www.dezorel.com
adam



spain Join date: 2009-09-05
Trade:
  • Yes

Posts: 4281
Location: Spain
Age: 42

PostSubject: Re: How much do you really need to spend to reach the high end sound?   Sun Apr 25, 2010 9:01 pm

dvv wrote:
Adam, I'd just love to be amazed by a 1.000 euro system, but unfortunately, I haven't been so far. Decent sounding - yes, it is possible, but it takes a lot to amaze me. Even if you buy vintage, after refreshing, it will cost more. But your point is not lost on me, it's true you don't need five figure systems for an honestly good sound.


I'm probably speaking in relative terms and not absolute, but I really think you can put together a lovely little study/bedroom like system that will bring great musical satisfaction for around that price with carefully chosen components.
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://www.eden-audio.com
 

How much do you really need to spend to reach the high end sound?

View previous topic View next topic Back to top 
Page 1 of 6Goto page : 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6  Next

 Similar topics

-
» Mod of Sound Image 3.2 - Charisma and Attraction Subliminal For Men (v.2), need instructions on how to use the mp3
» Episode idea: High School!
» Penelope Cruz - High Quality Animated GIFs
» Rachel Nichols - High Quality Animated GIFs
» Michelle Trachtenberg - High Quality Animated GIFs

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
MundoAudiofilo HiFi Forum :: Audio Chit Chat :: 2 Channel Audio-