MundoAudiofilo HiFi Forum

Meet fellow Audiophiles and Music lovers from around the world
 
HomeCalendarGalleryFAQSearchMemberlistUsergroupsRegisterLog in

Share | 
 

 What has happened to UK High Fidelity manufacturing

View previous topic View next topic Go down 
Goto page : 1, 2, 3, 4  Next
AuthorMessage
stan



England Join date: 2010-10-16
Trade:
  • No

Posts: 25

PostSubject: What has happened to UK High Fidelity manufacturing   Sat Oct 16, 2010 2:41 pm

Once Britannia ruled the waves when it came to audio innovation, they were looked up to and lead the way, with leading brands from Tannoy, Spendor, Rogers, Kef, B&W, Pro-Ac, Naim, Linn, Quad, Mission, Garrad, SME, Rega, Meridian, you could easily rattle a list as long as your arm of brands the rest of the world looked up to and admired, it was a symbol of how great this small cottage industry was in the eyes of the rest of the world, Britian was a leader when it came for audio innovation.

But roll forward few decades and the wheels have clearly come off the cart when it comes to UK innovation and new up coming manufactures. The UK has been eclipsed and surpassed by all, other countries have new manufactures with clever and innovative ideas, maybe nothing new sonically speaking, but t least they re making things, but what of sad Britain, we appear to be stuck in some muddy bog unable to move forward, can you think of any new makes and brands to come out of the UK in recent times, please spare me the usual excuses in that we can't compete, rubbish, we can compete, it's just we seem to have stopped trying, we've thrown in towel, or is it was just don't or we can't be bothered to make new things any more in this country?

How many new speakers designers are their compared to other countries?

How many new amplifier makers are there?

We have lost our way in designing, just what has happened to us here in the UK, once we lead the way, but now we hardly have any thing left. I'm sure there will be list of excuses but all countries can put forty excuses, but strangely the don't let the excuses get in the way, have we turned in to a nation of giver uppers?
Back to top Go down
View user profile
colin



England Join date: 2009-10-10
Trade:
  • No

Posts: 633
Location: north lincs

PostSubject: Re: What has happened to UK High Fidelity manufacturing   Sat Oct 16, 2010 7:22 pm

Its nice to see a new face, so sorry to start our conversation with what b....ks, what inovation has any one come up with in the last few years. OK we have had the advance of digital, but to be fair given how poor it was at the start the only way it could go was up. So we have needed new deigns for digital transports, and dacs, but as most of that has been built on the back of computer audio who did the building is a moot point.

Rega, Meridian, Linn, Naim, B&W, Pro Acc, SME, Tannoy and spendor are still around thanks, and all have product that can hold up its head in any market sector. Add to that Cyrus, Harbeth, Neat, Kudos, Roksan, Michell, and a list of others I don't think we have very much wrong with our home produced audio product.

On top of that. you name me one well designed, good sounding piece of kit that is a real step forward in audio design that has come out in the last 10 years. I mean something really new, not a new take on a old theme, or a computer dressed up in a hi fi box from any country.


Back to top Go down
View user profile
stan



England Join date: 2010-10-16
Trade:
  • No

Posts: 25

PostSubject: Re: What has happened to UK High Fidelity manufacturing   Sat Oct 16, 2010 7:38 pm

A warm welcome indeed.

But you have misinterpreted the point, how many new manufactures are there? I am aware we still have the familiar names that roll of the tongue when it comes to the British audio manufacturing scene, but my point is we re not seeing any new names compared to other countries and we are seriously lacking in this area, just look at the US, China, Germany, where new companies and innovative products re being investigated but in Britain we see the same names always. Nothing wrong at all with the products, it's just I'd like to see some new blood.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
adam



spain Join date: 2009-09-05
Trade:
  • Yes

Posts: 4276
Location: Spain
Age: 42

PostSubject: Re: What has happened to UK High Fidelity manufacturing   Sun Oct 17, 2010 8:59 am

You have to remember that the UK is very small compared to the USA or China, plus the trend today is to buy second hand so who in their right mind would want to go out and start a hifi company when so few are buying new? The market is small for new HiFi at the moment. But in the UK there are still some new names for example Leema, AstinTrew, Kudos, EB acoustics, Inspire, Beresford, and some cable makers, not a huge list but still well regarded products.
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://www.eden-audio.com
bushytip



England Join date: 2010-05-22
Trade:
  • No

Posts: 1247
Age: 30

PostSubject: Re: What has happened to UK High Fidelity manufacturing   Sun Oct 17, 2010 1:14 pm

A great new manufacturer or newish which I respect a great deal and make really good sounding kit is Anatek, I had a great pre and monos from them and Martyn whi runs the company can be contacted at home or on hus mobile, ive even had chats with him when hes been out of work hours and down the pub!

Back to top Go down
View user profile
Fnuckle



England Join date: 2010-04-03
Trade:
  • Yes

Posts: 205

PostSubject: Re: What has happened to UK High Fidelity manufacturing   Mon Oct 18, 2010 2:25 am

colin wrote:
Its nice to see a new face, so sorry to start our conversation with what b....ks, what inovation has any one come up with in the last few years. OK we have had the advance of digital, but to be fair given how poor it was at the start the only way it could go was up. So we have needed new deigns for digital transports, and dacs, but as most of that has been built on the back of computer audio who did the building is a moot point.

Rega, Meridian, Linn, Naim, B&W, Pro Acc, SME, Tannoy and spendor are still around thanks, and all have product that can hold up its head in any market sector. Add to that Cyrus, Harbeth, Neat, Kudos, Roksan, Michell, and a list of others I don't think we have very much wrong with our home produced audio product.

On top of that. you name me one well designed, good sounding piece of kit that is a real step forward in audio design that has come out in the last 10 years. I mean something really new, not a new take on a old theme, or a computer dressed up in a hi fi box from any country.




No, the OP's right. Had the UK audio business continued to fight above its weight the way it did from the 1950s-1980s, the Squeezebox would have been designed by Arcam, Naim would have made the D-Premier amp and Meridian would have developed ICEpower.

In addition, Tannoy, Wharfedale, Quad, Mission, Audiolab, Castle, KEF, B&W and Meridian would not be part or wholly offshore owned. The UK would have more than one surviving independent cabinet manufacturer for loudspeakers. Companies like Rega and Michell would continue to have the sort of reputation outside of the UK that they have inside the UK.

For the record, the innovative product of next year is the Storm Audio. It allows the listener to tailor the output impedance of the amplifier to match the loudspeaker, without resorting to some kind of transformer. That's never been done before and has a direct and positive and clearly audible influence on the overall sound. It is French. So is this year's big innovative product, the Devialet D-Premier. Neither of these products were trivial undertakings and show genuine blue-sky thinking about the way you approach making an amplifier.

So, instead of trying to ignore the presence of real and legitimate innovation in audio, ask yourself where the next great game changer is going to come from? It's almost certainly not going to be from the UK.

Why this is so is simple. Some countries don't like the idea of a brain drain and support technologies and manufacturers who innovate. The UK wants to be post-industrial and hopes that engineers don't get in the way of the important job of bailing out millionaire bankers. Guess which one delivers new products?
Back to top Go down
View user profile
colin



England Join date: 2009-10-10
Trade:
  • No

Posts: 633
Location: north lincs

PostSubject: Re: What has happened to UK High Fidelity manufacturing   Mon Oct 18, 2010 7:07 am

Sorry, but I have not seen anything that inivotive in hi-fi from any hi-fi brand from within these shores, or outside them for a number of years. Any changes have either been on the back of computer hardware or a spin on something existing. as For ICEPower amps etc, when I hear one that offers a better sound than a traditional amp, maybe I'll get interested. A number of brands may have become offshore based and financed, but that could quite simply down to a fore ever shrinking market. And what have any of the ChiBrit companies brought to the market beyond cheap labour and components, nothing really new thats for sure. In the 50's to the 80's after the purchase of a car and house the next must have for most people was a decent sound system. How many homes do you know with that aspiration now. I may be getting to be a sad old sod, but I have seen very little come to market over the last few years that would make me reach for my cheque book, and what has, has either been a refinement of a theme, or a ease of use thing.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
stan



England Join date: 2010-10-16
Trade:
  • No

Posts: 25

PostSubject: Re: What has happened to UK High Fidelity manufacturing   Mon Oct 18, 2010 9:51 am

Fnuckle has summoned up my thoughts, we've stopped innovating and leading the way, but we've become masters of repackaging, we make pretty but the same themed HiFi over and over again, we've stood sail and watched the world sale by, does any one want to offer an explanation like colin above as to why? I see where he is coming from, but I still think we are stuck in a sticky audio bog in this country.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Fnuckle



England Join date: 2010-04-03
Trade:
  • Yes

Posts: 205

PostSubject: Re: What has happened to UK High Fidelity manufacturing   Mon Oct 18, 2010 10:58 am

A lot of this comes down to the severe lack of interest from UK buyers.

What's the point in a start-up trying to develop something innovative in the UK market when it's met by people who dismiss innovation for being innovative? Start-ups need to build in the home market before they can grow an export market. They can't do that if the home audience fears the new, especially when the only chance of entrepreneurial funding from government sources happens if you are an IT start-up.

Compare this with the French market. The government backs the projects because it wants France to be a technology leader. People there see cool new things as cool and new. You can see the same connection in places like Germany, Japan, China and Denmark.

The lack of interest in the market makes this not a rich environment to launch innovative products. The lack of potential funding means you have to be in an established company to develop products, and an established company is usually keen to produce more of the same rather than striking innovation.

In fairness, companies like Linn and Naim are doing some serious development in streaming and computer audio products. And, true to form, a lot of this is being thoroughly dismissed by many UK hi-fi enthusiasts, who want the world frozen in 1988 time.

Back to top Go down
View user profile
colin



England Join date: 2009-10-10
Trade:
  • No

Posts: 633
Location: north lincs

PostSubject: Re: What has happened to UK High Fidelity manufacturing   Mon Oct 18, 2010 11:56 am

I can not speak for others, but for myself I have not seen anything stunning come out of computer audio for a while. I use, and have used computer audio in my home office for 12 or more years. I currently use a windows XP machine running headless as a file store, external back up system, and audio player. Its nothing stunning, but it puts music out into my office through a Sansui amp and some half way decent speakers. The machine uses slimserver, or whatever it is currently called, and the squeezeplayer. Ths allows me to control the music through a web browser from any machine on the network. The main difference in this system over the 12 or so years is actually the size/cost per GTB of hard dries. It means that the music can be stored lossless. Hardly a stunning Hi-Fi advance. It also means that should I choose to, I could run a squeezebox from it into my main system. I choose not to stiking with CD instead. Why- is very simple, if I moved over to streamed music and the server, or player went dowm while I was away on business, I very much doubt if any one else in the house has the knowledge or interest to get it up and running again.

These advances, if that is what they are, are computer advances, played through a hi-fi system, not hi-fi advances.

I keep being told that i is more convient to use ripped music streamed, and you can box your CD's up and put them away. As my CD's, and some vinyl. has already been ripped it would not be a major project, just add a squeeze box and a DAC to the system, say £8-£900 and it would equal the sound of my £8-900 pound CD player/ Well bloody wonderful- wheres the advantage? Well your CD's can go away- when I run out of wall space for them I may see that as an advantage, but till them I'll stay as I am. And the wall full of vinyl will not be going anywhere thanks.

So come on and tell this old fossil what MAJOR advances have we missed out on because of the state of UK manufacturing of Hi-Fi.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
adam



spain Join date: 2009-09-05
Trade:
  • Yes

Posts: 4276
Location: Spain
Age: 42

PostSubject: Re: What has happened to UK High Fidelity manufacturing   Mon Oct 18, 2010 12:05 pm

Fnuckle wrote:
A lot of this comes down to the severe lack of interest from UK buyers.

What's the point in a start-up trying to develop something innovative in the UK market when it's met by people who dismiss innovation for being innovative? Start-ups need to build in the home market before they can grow an export market. They can't do that if the home audience fears the new, especially when the only chance of entrepreneurial funding from government sources happens if you are an IT start-up.


In fairness, companies like Linn and Naim are doing some serious development in streaming and computer audio products. And, true to form, a lot of this is being thoroughly dismissed by many UK hi-fi enthusiasts, who want the world frozen in 1988 time.



The problem I see from the UK is the general advice is always to buy second hand, while I see the sense in this it's doesn't encourage innovation, what is the point in spending money developing a product only for it to never sell and people to buy products from the 1980, maybe Colin is right in that today audio is no better, but when I see around me I see some really innovative designs and products hitting the market, I do actually include some British companies in that.

The problem I see with Linn and naim and a few others is the entry level access to these products is still high hence people will stick to the IPod.
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://www.eden-audio.com
Jilly



England Join date: 2010-08-27
Trade:
  • No

Posts: 1130

PostSubject: Re: What has happened to UK High Fidelity manufacturing   Mon Oct 18, 2010 1:07 pm

Bank bailout-biggest transfer of wealth since the Norman invasion-can you imagine what difference that amount would make to the crumbling infrastructure of this country?Hard to tackle this question without becoming political-or as the old saying goes-the fish rots from the head downwards
The UK has always made a stark difference between manual and non manual skills-this goes back to the need to train an elite cicvil service to run the empire.We were conditioned to worship the axioms of finance capital and now we are experiencing the fruits of this ....other countries carry no such historical baggage
Other european states such as Germany protect their industries from speculative predators but we basically sold off the UK to enrich a minority
So the concentration has been on repackaging and marketing techniques-hence the fame of charlatans like Sugar and his ilk
We have only ourselves to blame-people get the governments they deserve sometimes it seems while the city elites despise us as a mass....
Whatever the economics of companies like Naim they are ridiculously expensive to anyone wishing to dip a toe into hi-fi as Adam said so its no surprise that people choose what to them seems a better deal.The biggest investments and returns on innovation now seem all to be military-where the investor class know theyll get a good return in an age of imperial war.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Fnuckle



England Join date: 2010-04-03
Trade:
  • Yes

Posts: 205

PostSubject: Re: What has happened to UK High Fidelity manufacturing   Mon Oct 18, 2010 2:44 pm

colin wrote:
I can not speak for others, but for myself I have not seen anything stunning come out of computer audio for a while. I use, and have used computer audio in my home office for 12 or more years. I currently use a windows XP machine running headless as a file store, external back up system, and audio player. Its nothing stunning, but it puts music out into my office through a Sansui amp and some half way decent speakers. The machine uses slimserver, or whatever it is currently called, and the squeezeplayer. Ths allows me to control the music through a web browser from any machine on the network. The main difference in this system over the 12 or so years is actually the size/cost per GTB of hard dries. It means that the music can be stored lossless. Hardly a stunning Hi-Fi advance. It also means that should I choose to, I could run a squeezebox from it into my main system. I choose not to stiking with CD instead. Why- is very simple, if I moved over to streamed music and the server, or player went dowm while I was away on business, I very much doubt if any one else in the house has the knowledge or interest to get it up and running again.

These advances, if that is what they are, are computer advances, played through a hi-fi system, not hi-fi advances.

I keep being told that i is more convient to use ripped music streamed, and you can box your CD's up and put them away. As my CD's, and some vinyl. has already been ripped it would not be a major project, just add a squeeze box and a DAC to the system, say £8-£900 and it would equal the sound of my £8-900 pound CD player/ Well bloody wonderful- wheres the advantage? Well your CD's can go away- when I run out of wall space for them I may see that as an advantage, but till them I'll stay as I am. And the wall full of vinyl will not be going anywhere thanks.

So come on and tell this old fossil what MAJOR advances have we missed out on because of the state of UK manufacturing of Hi-Fi.


Power DACs and Class ADH. Neither could happen in the UK, because no one would or could afford to fund the projects. Put the two together and you have a product that pretty much redefines high-fidelity. And because the outcome of such projects would be met by the sort of abject dismissal you seem to have about post-physical music sources.

Your dismissal of what happens after CD can in fact only really happen in the UK now, because our CD market is artificially buoyed by the likes of HMV. It's why CD sales are only down about 80% compared to the 2000 figures in the UK. That's the big advantage to your squeezebox; record companies are itching to be rid of physical formats - some classical labels have already made the jump to download-only for back-catalogue material.

No matter how much you might want to be the arbiter of what is good and bad, you are not. So, you can't just simply modify what does and does not constitute a major advance on the grounds that you don't personally like it. You may not care for the squeezebox, but to suggest it isn't an audio innovation because it's a just another computer is absurd. What the hell do you think a CD player is? It's a dedicated, single-function digital audio computer.

So, in answer to your question; Class D, DSP room correction, slimserver, Spotify, high quality wireless music across AC power lines, asynchronous USB, Class ADH, Class T, Sonos, Sooloos, ICEpower Leedh and StormFocus all represent significant improvements to what is effectively an industry that - CD aside - stopped innovating in about 1964. And very little of that innovation has taken place inside the UK and what little that has (from Linn and Naim) you dismiss as being irrelevant because you don't like the concept of computer audio, even though your CDs are basically played on a computer.



Back to top Go down
View user profile
inkpost



Canada Join date: 2010-10-03
Trade:
  • No

Posts: 15

PostSubject: Re: What has happened to UK High Fidelity manufacturing   Mon Oct 18, 2010 2:51 pm

Governments are finally waking up to the realization you need to make things, people need jobs, they need to be taught for future generations.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
adam



spain Join date: 2009-09-05
Trade:
  • Yes

Posts: 4276
Location: Spain
Age: 42

PostSubject: Re: What has happened to UK High Fidelity manufacturing   Mon Oct 18, 2010 3:36 pm

I thought the Sonneteer morpheus was innovative and British but it seems that any thing new from Britain these days is brushed to one side and doesn't get some of the recognition it deserves, I think it's down to same old story of money talks.
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://www.eden-audio.com
 

What has happened to UK High Fidelity manufacturing

View previous topic View next topic Back to top 
Page 1 of 4Goto page : 1, 2, 3, 4  Next

 Similar topics

-
» Penelope Cruz - High Quality Animated GIFs
» What has happened to UK High Fidelity manufacturing
» KingRex UD01Pro USB DAC review in High fidelity.pl
» Are film stars tweeting their careers into oblivion? George mention
» Great RCA Victor Ad

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
MundoAudiofilo HiFi Forum :: Audio Chit Chat :: 2 Channel Audio-